Apart from being praised as an ethical work-around to the problems of destroying early-stage human embryos—often about to be discarded as surplusage by fertility clinics — to obtain human pluripotent stem cells, Revazova et al. (U.S. Pat. No. 7732202 – copy at end of post) got relatively little attention from the IP community. I predict that the relatively benign reception that this patent got will change as various groups begin to sort through the claims and 138 columns of disclosure. Dolly, the cloned ewe, was made by removing the nucleus from an oocyte, or unfertilized ovum, of one breed of sheep, and replacing it with nuclear material from an adult donor cell taken from a different breed of sheep. The renucleated oocyte was induced to divide by an electrical pulse, and reimplanted in a surrogate mother, that eventually gave birth to Dolly, who looked just like the sheep that donated the nuclear material. The donor sheep had successfully been cloned. Today you can clone Fluffy, your favorite cat or, if the USDA would allow it, eat a burger made from beef from a cloned herd of steers. In 1998, Tompson et al. at the University of Wisconsin, claimed human embryonic stem cells obtained by disassembling blastocysts, or very early stage fertilized eggs. In 83 JPTOS 830 (Nov. 2001), I wrote:
“The debate about reproductive or therapeutic cloning of individuals has become interlocked with the ethical controversy that has accompanied a new area of science broadly termed “stem cell technology.” This area of research is based on the discovery that cells of the early mammalian embryo, including those from the blastocyst, can be cultured in vitro so as to proliferate indefinitely in an undifferentiated state. More importantly, the cells are pluripotent, in that they can be induced by various cytokines to form derivatives of all three embryonic germ layers. These “[embryonic] stem cells” (ES) have enormous potential for both drug discovery and direct therapeutic applications….Combined with cloning techniques, the use of ES theoretically permits an individual to clone him/herself in early embryonic form in order to obtain and differentiate stem cells into tissue that could be used for an autologous transplant, …or even to create synthetic organs.”

